Home Drag and Drop API: Why It Fails on Firefox and Chrome?

Web Development

Drag and Drop API: Why It Fails on Firefox and Chrome?

Struggling with drag and drop between browser windows? Learn how drag and drop API behaves on Chrome vs Firefox and what to use instead.

byDev Solutions

December 31, 2025

Illustration of a developer struggling with drag and drop between Chrome and Firefox browser windows, showing broken file transfer and confused expression

⚠️ Cross-window drag-and-drop using the native API can silently fail on Firefox and Chrome due to strict security boundaries.
💡 The DataTransfer object supports only basic types like 'text/plain' and has serious limitations across browser contexts.
🧪 Custom MIME types like 'application/json' fail to persist in drag sessions between windows.
🔧 Developers can bypass native API limitations using storage APIs, postMessage, and libraries like React DnD.
🖱️ Drag-and-drop across tabs or windows is inconsistent and requires careful testing on each target browser.

Drag and Drop API: Why It Fails on Firefox and Chrome?

If you have ever tried to add drag and drop features across browser windows, you likely found some frustrating problems. The HTML5 Drag and Drop API often does not work as expected. Many developers run into confusing bugs when they test on Chrome versus Firefox, especially when moving items between windows. We will look at what happens, why it fails, and how to get around these problems with better tools and methods.

How the Drag and Drop API Works

The HTML5 Drag and Drop API lets developers handle drag actions. It uses a set of user input events and a way to move data. Here is how it works:

Core Event Flow

dragstart – This event starts a drag. Here, you fill the DataTransfer object using setData(). You can also change the drag image or start visual effects.
drag – This event keeps firing as you drag the item.
dragenter and dragover – These events happen when the item you are dragging enters and moves over a place it can be dropped.
dragleave – This event happens when the item leaves a drop zone.
drop – This event runs the main code once you drop the item. You get the data using getData().
dragend – This event cleans things up after the drag ends, no matter if you dropped or canceled it.

The `DataTransfer` Object: Central API Unit

Every dragstart and drop event has a DataTransfer object. With it, you can:

Use setData(format, data) to put string data in.
Call getData(format) to get strings if the format is the same.
Add files for dropping by changing .files, if you want to.

This DataTransfer object seems useful, but browsers limit it a lot because of security rules. Also, it cannot reliably move complex data that is not text, like JavaScript objects, even when you turn them into strings.

The Cross-Window Challenge

Drag and drop usually works fine inside one browser window. But it quickly breaks when you try to move data between different browser windows or tabs.

What Goes Wrong?

When you drag something between two windows, the DataTransfer object holds the drag data for a short time. But it has many limits. Each window or tab usually runs in its own secure space. This stops certain data formats from staying with the drag. It also affects whether the drag event finishes at all.

Browser-Specific Differences

Google Chrome: It lets text/plain go between windows or tabs. But it usually removes custom MIME types, like application/json, without telling you.
Mozilla Firefox: This browser is more careful. It often throws away even simple data formats when you drag between windows.

Why It's a Problem

Separating windows like this is a security rule. It stops bad scripts from taking your private data. This rule is important. But it also means drag-and-drop acts differently based on:

The browser you use.
The kind of data you send to dataTransfer.
What the user is allowed to do.
How the operating system handles dragging (especially when you drag from outside the browser).

These things make drag and drop work in ways that are not always the same. This makes it hard to find problems, especially when you work across different windows.

Developer Reality Check

Always expect that DataTransfer data will not carry over when you switch windows or tabs.
Use cross-window drag events as a sign that something is happening, not as a way to move data itself.

Why Firefox and Chrome Behave Differently

Both browsers follow HTML5 rules. But they understand and apply the drag and drop rules in their own ways. This is true for security and how they handle MIME types.

Firefox’s Conservative Take

Firefox puts data privacy first when moving it between windows. Its drag code strongly blocks almost all custom setData() items during cross-window drags. So, even harmless types like text/html or application/json might be lost before they get to where they are going.

❌ Only safe data from the operating system, like file names or text/plain, sometimes gets through.
🔐 Custom types are not allowed to keep the secure window separation strong, even between tabs from the same website.

Chrome’s More Permissive Approach

Chrome is a bit less strict than Firefox. You can sometimes send complex data, like JSON strings, if you make them text/plain. But users have said that drop events sometimes do not happen at all when custom types are involved.

✅ Chrome lets you use more types, but it does not promise the data will be exactly the same.
🚫 Drop events can stop working without a clear sign if Chrome thinks the data types are not safe.

📊 Mozilla's website says that custom data added with setData() might not stay when moved between browser windows. This is for security reasons.

The Limitations of the `DataTransfer` Object

To see why drag-and-drop breaks in hard situations, developers must know what the DataTransfer interface cannot do.

What DataTransfer Allows

Simple string types like these:
- text/plain
- text/uri-list
Files using dataTransfer.files when dragging from your computer.
Basic things for visual drag feedback, such as allowed effects (copy, move, link).

What It Rejects or Drops

Data that is not text (e.g., images, blobs)
MIME types that are not known.
Objects from other parts of the browser (e.g., DOM elements, closures).
Complex data types like application/json, even if they are turned into strings.

Bottom Line

✅ Use DataTransfer for simple labels or website links.
🚫 Do not count on it to send program rules, JSON data, or session information.

Real Bugs and Odd Behaviors

Drag and drop bugs are not rare. They are real problems that developers have found and checked.

Noteworthy Examples:

Chrome (v118+) – Drop events might not happen if you drag between windows. This is often true if you do not handle dragover.preventDefault() correctly.
Firefox (post v107) – Firefox strongly removes custom MIME types, even between tabs from the same website.
Custom MIME Types – Types like application/json or special company formats are seen as not safe. They are ignored or deleted without a warning. This makes them not trustworthy.

Verified Bug Reports

Find examples on the Chrome Status Tracker and the Mozilla Bugzilla forums. These talk about how things are not the same in different versions.

🔍 Developers have reported and checked these bug actions. This shows how easily cross-browser drag and drop breaks when you use anything more than the simplest types.

Debugging Drag and Drop Issues

Finding drag and drop problems can seem hard. Here is how to make it easier.

Steps for Better Debugging

Check Event Order
- Use console.log(event.type) inside each drag event.
- See if events happen in the right order: dragstart → drag → dragover → drop.
Look at DataTransfer
- Log event.dataTransfer.types and what getData() returns.
- Check if the data is there before and after you move it.
Test in a Set Up Area
- Tabs from the same website.
- Apps with one page versus apps with many pages.
- How it acts on a computer versus a phone.
Add Backup Logs
- Log localStorage writes and postMessage events if you use them.
- Look at network traffic if you use other ways to get data.

Developer Guidance

🕵️ Check for features, not browsers. And expect very little support when moving things between windows.
🧭 Follow dataTransfer.types at each step to find where it stops working.

Best Practices for Reliable Implementation

To make a drag and drop system that works well:

✅ DO:

Use formats that work everywhere: 'text/plain', 'text/uri-list'.
Add event.preventDefault() to dragover events. The drop event will not happen without it.
Make sure to show visual signs with dragenter, dragleave, and custom CSS for where you can drop items.

🚫 DON'T:

Do not count on DataTransfer for data formats that are hard to use.
Do not skip testing on Firefox or when moving items between windows.
Do not think that if it works in one window, it will also work between windows.

🛠️ Good designs use drag visuals and true data sharing logic together.

Smarter Alternatives to the Native API

When the built-in drag code does not work, add better ways to handle it.

JavaScript Libraries Worth Using

React DnD: This drag tool works with many JavaScript frameworks. It is built using Redux methods.
Interact.js: It works with touch, keeps things moving smoothly, helps items snap into place, and limits how you can interact.
SortableJS / Dragula: These make it easier to reorder parts of a webpage. They offer a simple way to do it.

postMessage() – Send messages between tabs, windows, or parts of a page.
BroadcastChannel – This lets one tab send messages to many other tabs. Newer browsers support it.
localStorage + polling – This is not the best way, but it works to share small amounts of data between tabs.

Use these methods together in a smart way:

Use the drag action just for how it looks and feels.
Send the real data using one of the message-passing methods listed above.

When to Use JavaScript Libraries

Built-in drag events can only do so much. JavaScript libraries make things much easier when you need to handle how items work, what types they are, and complex interactions.

Benefits of Using Libraries

Drag event rules that are the same everywhere.
Ways to handle data that are separate from drag actions.
Help for users with disabilities, instant visual signs, and touch screens.
Easier to test.

🧩 DnD libraries help you make complex lists, pop-ups, and control panels. They ensure dragging works the same on all devices.

Instead of fighting the system, work with it.

Reliable Strategies

Use window.postMessage – This clearly separates how something looks from what it actually does.
BroadcastChannel API – This is a built-in way to send messages to many tabs at once. Newer browsers use it.
localStorage Flags – This is a simple fix. You write content to localStorage, and another tab or window checks it often.

How it Works (Example)

A user drags something from Window A.
The drag action starts a setItem() or postMessage() with data.
Window B gets the data and shows a visual response.
The screen changes to show the new data.

Think of drag and drop as a signal to act, not a box that holds data.

Testing Strategies Across Browsers

Testing is very important because things do not always work the same way.

Manual Test Scenarios

Drag from tab A to tab B with simple and custom data types.
Drag to and from files on your computer versus items inside the browser.
Check how it acts across the newest versions of Chrome, Firefox, and Edge.

Tools to Use

Browser DevTools – Look at event.dataTransfer. Log the types and data at each step.
BrowserStack/SauceLabs – Try out drag actions on many different operating systems and browser mixes.
Automated DOM Testing – If you use libraries, pretend to drag things for quick checks or unit tests.

⌨️ Even good code will not work if you do not check it in the places where people will use it. Doing tests by hand is important.

Wrapping It Up

The HTML5 Drag and Drop API is good for simple things. But it has limits. This makes it a bad choice for sharing complex data between windows. Both Firefox and Chrome have strict security around the DataTransfer object. This causes data to be lost, events to be missed, and bad user experiences if you do not handle it right.

Final Recommendations:

Keep DataTransfer simple. Only use standard string or file types.
See cross-window drag and drop as a visual sign, not a way to move data.
Add to drag actions with APIs like postMessage, localStorage, or BroadcastChannel.
Use libraries that are known to work well, like React DnD or SortableJS. These help hide event differences and make things work better.

For stronger ways to build front ends, especially in apps with many tabs, stop relying only on the drag and drop API. Combine good screen interaction with firm data handling to make cross-window drag and drop work well and in a steady way.