Follow

Keep Up to Date with the Most Important News

By pressing the Subscribe button, you confirm that you have read and are agreeing to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use
Contact

Why does subsetting work in some cases and not others?

I have a large dataframe (t2m.all) with longitude (lon), latitude (lat) and hourly temperatures since 1958 (X1958.01.01.00.00.00). A subset of the data is given in the code below:

dput(t2m.all[1:300,1:3])
structure(list(Lon = c(-102, -101.9, -101.8, -101.7, -101.6, 
-101.5, -101.4, -101.3, -101.2, -101.1, -101, -100.9, -100.8, 
-100.7, -100.6, -100.5, -100.4, -100.3, -100.2, -100.1, -100, 
-99.9, -99.8, -99.7, -99.6, -99.5, -99.4, -99.3, -99.2, -99.1, 
-99, -98.9, -98.8, -98.7, -98.6, -98.5, -98.4, -98.3, -98.2, 
-98.1, -98, -97.9, -97.8, -97.7, -97.6, -97.5, -97.4, -97.3, 
-97.2, -97.1, -97, -96.9, -96.8, -96.7, -96.6, -96.5, -96.4, 
-96.3, -96.2, -96.1, -96, -95.9, -95.8, -95.7, -95.6, -95.5, 
-95.4, -95.3, -95.2, -95.1, -95, -102, -101.9, -101.8, -101.7, 
-101.6, -101.5, -101.4, -101.3, -101.2, -101.1, -101, -100.9, 
-100.8, -100.7, -100.6, -100.5, -100.4, -100.3, -100.2, -100.1, 
-100, -99.9, -99.8, -99.7, -99.6, -99.5, -99.4, -99.3, -99.2, 
-99.1, -99, -98.9, -98.8, -98.7, -98.6, -98.5, -98.4, -98.3, 
-98.2, -98.1, -98, -97.9, -97.8, -97.7, -97.6, -97.5, -97.4, 
-97.3, -97.2, -97.1, -97, -96.9, -96.8, -96.7, -96.6, -96.5, 
-96.4, -96.3, -96.2, -96.1, -96, -95.9, -95.8, -95.7, -95.6, 
-95.5, -95.4, -95.3, -95.2, -95.1, -95, -102, -101.9, -101.8, 
-101.7, -101.6, -101.5, -101.4, -101.3, -101.2, -101.1, -101, 
-100.9, -100.8, -100.7, -100.6, -100.5, -100.4, -100.3, -100.2, 
-100.1, -100, -99.9, -99.8, -99.7, -99.6, -99.5, -99.4, -99.3, 
-99.2, -99.1, -99, -98.9, -98.8, -98.7, -98.6, -98.5, -98.4, 
-98.3, -98.2, -98.1, -98, -97.9, -97.8, -97.7, -97.6, -97.5, 
-97.4, -97.3, -97.2, -97.1, -97, -96.9, -96.8, -96.7, -96.6, 
-96.5, -96.4, -96.3, -96.2, -96.1, -96, -95.9, -95.8, -95.7, 
-95.6, -95.5, -95.4, -95.3, -95.2, -95.1, -95, -94.9, -102, -101.9, 
-101.8, -101.7, -101.6, -101.5, -101.4, -101.3, -101.2, -101.1, 
-101, -100.9, -100.8, -100.7, -100.6, -100.5, -100.4, -100.3, 
-100.2, -100.1, -100, -99.9, -99.8, -99.7, -99.6, -99.5, -99.4, 
-99.3, -99.2, -99.1, -99, -98.9, -98.8, -98.7, -98.6, -98.5, 
-98.4, -98.3, -98.2, -98.1, -98, -97.9, -97.8, -97.7, -97.6, 
-97.5, -97.4, -97.3, -97.2, -97.1, -97, -96.9, -96.8, -96.7, 
-96.6, -96.5, -96.4, -96.3, -96.2, -96.1, -96, -95.9, -95.8, 
-95.7, -95.6, -95.5, -95.4, -95.3, -95.2, -95.1, -95, -94.9, 
-102, -101.9, -101.8, -101.7, -101.6, -101.5, -101.4, -101.3, 
-101.2, -101.1, -101, -100.9, -100.8, -100.7), Lat = c(60, 60, 
60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 
60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 
60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 
60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 
60, 60, 60, 60, 60, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 
59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 
59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 
59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 
59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 
59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 
59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.9, 59.8, 59.8, 
59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 
59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 
59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 
59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 
59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 
59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 
59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.8, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 
59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 
59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 
59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 
59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 
59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 
59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.7, 59.6, 
59.6, 59.6, 59.6, 59.6, 59.6, 59.6, 59.6, 59.6, 59.6, 59.6, 59.6, 
59.6, 59.6), X1958.01.01.00.00.00 = c(-37.2, -37.2, -36.6, -35.9, 
-36, -36.1, -35.8, -35.5, -35.1, -34.7, -34.2, -33.6, -33.6, 
-34, -33.8, -33.2, -32.8, -32.6, -32.5, -32.5, -32.4, -32.3, 
-32.3, -32.7, -33.1, -33.2, -33.3, -33.3, -33.3, -33.1, -32.9, 
-32.6, -32.4, -32.1, -31.8, -31.5, -31.2, -30.9, -30.6, -30.3, 
-30, -29.7, -29.4, -29.1, -28.8, -28.5, -28.2, -27.9, -27.7, 
-27.4, -27.1, -26.8, -26.6, -26.3, -26.1, -25.9, -25.6, -25.4, 
-25.2, -24.9, -24.7, -24.4, -24.1, -23.8, -23.6, -23.3, -23, 
-22.7, -22.4, -22.1, -21.9, -36.6, -37.1, -36.6, -36.1, -36, 
-36.1, -35.7, -35, -34.6, -34.8, -34.7, -34, -33.8, -33.7, -33.6, 
-33.2, -32.4, -32.3, -32.3, -32.3, -32.3, -32.8, -32.9, -32.7, 
-33, -33.1, -33.1, -33.1, -33.1, -33, -32.8, -32.5, -32.3, -32.1, 
-31.8, -31.5, -31.2, -30.9, -30.6, -30.3, -30.1, -29.8, -29.4, 
-29.1, -28.8, -28.5, -28.3, -28, -27.7, -27.4, -27.1, -26.9, 
-26.6, -26.4, -26.1, -25.9, -25.6, -25.4, -25.2, -24.9, -24.7, 
-24.4, -24.1, -23.9, -23.6, -23.3, -23, -22.8, -22.5, -22.2, 
-21.9, -36.7, -36.8, -36.8, -36.4, -36.2, -36, -35.9, -35.2, 
-34.6, -34.6, -34.4, -34.2, -34.2, -33.8, -33.3, -32.7, -32.3, 
-32.2, -32.3, -32.6, -33.3, -33.5, -33.2, -33.1, -32.5, -32.2, 
-32.7, -33, -32.9, -32.8, -32.6, -32.5, -32.2, -32, -31.7, -31.5, 
-31.2, -30.9, -30.6, -30.4, -30.1, -29.8, -29.5, -29.2, -28.9, 
-28.6, -28.3, -28, -27.7, -27.4, -27.2, -26.9, -26.7, -26.4, 
-26.2, -25.9, -25.7, -25.4, -25.2, -24.9, -24.7, -24.4, -24.2, 
-23.9, -23.6, -23.4, -23.1, -22.8, -22.5, -22.3, -22, -21.9, 
-36.6, -36.6, -36.5, -36.3, -36.2, -35.7, -35.1, -34.5, -34.1, 
-34.5, -34.7, -34, -33.3, -33, -32.6, -32.6, -32.8, -33, -33.3, 
-33.2, -32.9, -32.9, -33, -32.9, -33, -33.1, -33, -33, -32.9, 
-32.8, -32.6, -32.4, -32.2, -32, -31.7, -31.4, -31.2, -31, -30.7, 
-30.4, -30.1, -29.8, -29.4, -29.1, -28.8, -28.5, -28.3, -28, 
-27.8, -27.5, -27.2, -26.9, -26.7, -26.4, -26.1, -25.9, -25.6, 
-25.4, -25.2, -24.9, -24.7, -24.4, -24.2, -23.9, -23.6, -23.4, 
-23.1, -22.9, -22.6, -22.3, -22, -21.9, -36.4, -36.3, -36, -35.7, 
-35.3, -34.5, -34.3, -34.5, -34.5, -34.3, -33.9, -33.5, -33.2, 
-32.9)), row.names = c(NA, 300L), class = "data.frame")

I wish to subset t2m.all to isolate a single row returning the temperature value for a specified latitude and longitude pairing. This works for some coordinates but strangely not for others. For example, the below code works for these coordinates:

res = subset(t2m.all, Lon == -100.7 & Lat == 59.8)

but does not work for these coordinates:

MEDevel.com: Open-source for Healthcare and Education

Collecting and validating open-source software for healthcare, education, enterprise, development, medical imaging, medical records, and digital pathology.

Visit Medevel

res = subset(t2m.all, Lon == -100.7 & Lat == 59.6)

Both set of coordinates are clearly in the t2m.all dataframe, so why can R subset for some sets of coordinates but not for others? The logic seems sound to me, so I’m not sure what can be wrong. I have spent a long time going through all possibilities and troubleshooting on Stackoverflow, but I have yet to find a solution. Any suggestions? Many thanks in advance.

>Solution :

The issue results from round-off errors. You could set a tolerance value when comparing Lon & Lat with a certain value. In base you could use abs(x-y) < 1e-5 to achieve it:

t2m.all |>
  subset(abs(Lon - -100.7) < 1e-5 & abs(Lat - 59.6) < 1e-5)

#      Lon  Lat X1958.01.01.00.00.00
# 1 -100.7 59.6                -32.9

The dplyr equivalent is near():

library(dplyr)

t2m.all %>% 
  filter(near(Lon, -100.7) & near(Lat, 59.6))

#      Lon  Lat X1958.01.01.00.00.00
# 1 -100.7 59.6                -32.9
Add a comment

Leave a Reply

Keep Up to Date with the Most Important News

By pressing the Subscribe button, you confirm that you have read and are agreeing to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use

Discover more from Dev solutions

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading